Florida is a seafood lover’s paradise, and stone crab season is the perfect time to indulge in this sweet, succulent delicacy. From bustling waterfront cafes to high-end dining destinations, the Sunshine State offers plenty of spots to savor the best stone crab claws. Here’s our list of the top five restaurants for stone crab in Florida, with the legendary Key Largo Fisheries Café proudly taking the number one spot.
1. Key Largo Fisheries Café – Key Largo
Why It’s the Best:
Nestled in the heart of the Florida Keys, Key Largo Fisheries Café is a seafood gem offering some of the freshest stone crab claws in the state. This family-run establishment is renowned for its commitment to quality and sustainability, serving claws that are expertly cracked and paired with their signature tangy mustard sauce. The relaxed, waterfront setting adds to the charm, making it the ultimate spot for enjoying stone crab in a laid-back yet authentic atmosphere.
Must-Try: Chilled stone crab claws with a side of their famous Key Lime Pie for dessert.
Bonus: If you fall in love with their stone crabs (and you will), you can purchase claws to-go or have them shipped nationwide from their market.
2. Joe’s Stone Crab – Miami Beach
Why It’s a Classic:
Since 1913, Joe’s Stone Crab has been a landmark for seafood enthusiasts. Located in South Beach, this iconic restaurant helped put stone crab on the culinary map. Joe’s is famous for its impeccable service, old-school charm, and a menu that highlights the freshest stone crab claws in a luxurious dining environment.
Must-Try: A platter of jumbo stone crab claws with their signature hash browns and creamed spinach.
Tip: Arrive early—Joe’s doesn’t take reservations, and the wait can be long during stone crab season.
3. Billy’s Stone Crab – Hollywood
Why It Stands Out:
Located along the Intracoastal Waterway, Billy’s Stone Crab offers a stunning waterfront view to complement its mouthwatering seafood menu. Known for its fresh stone crab claws, Billy’s also features a retail market for guests who want to take some of their delicacies home. Their outdoor seating area makes it a great spot for enjoying Florida’s beautiful weather.
Must-Try: Stone crab claws served warm with drawn butter and a side of Billy’s homemade coleslaw.
Bonus: Arrive by boat and dock at their private slips.
4. The Fish House – Key Largo
Why It’s a Local Favorite:
Another Key Largo hotspot, The Fish House, is a cozy, unpretentious seafood haven that prides itself on locally sourced stone crab claws. Their chefs prepare the claws with care, ensuring the natural sweetness shines through. With its casual vibe and excellent service, The Fish House is a must-visit for anyone exploring the Keys.
Must-Try: Stone crab claws paired with their creamy New England clam chowder.
Tip: Visit during happy hour for great deals on drinks and appetizers.
5. Frenchy’s Café – Clearwater Beach
Why It’s Worth the Trip:
Located on Florida’s Gulf Coast, Frenchy’s Café is a laid-back beachside restaurant that delivers big on flavor. Famous for its vibrant atmosphere and unbeatable Gulf views, Frenchy’s is a fantastic place to indulge in Florida’s freshest stone crab claws during the season.
Must-Try: A basket of stone crab claws paired with their zesty Key West mustard sauce.
Bonus: Their lively bar is a great spot to enjoy a tropical cocktail while you wait for your claws.
Plan Your Stone Crab Adventure
Florida’s seafood scene is unrivaled, and these top restaurants prove it. Whether you’re savoring the claws at the iconic Key Largo Fisheries Café or indulging in the legendary experience at Joe’s Stone Crab, you’ll find unforgettable flavors and warm hospitality.
Don’t forget—stone crab season runs from October to May, so plan your visit and enjoy this uniquely Floridian treat while it’s at its freshest!