FAQS

Stone crab serving

Stone Crab of Key Largo, Florida, operates 2 South Florida fish houses in Marathon and Summerland Key. Over 40 boats supply our fish houses with daily catches of stone crab, lobster, and fish. We are the producer as well as the end-user. Our handling of the product from start to finish before our customers receive it makes our services unique.

We sell stone crabs and many other products, including grouper fillet, snapper fillet, Mahi-mahi fillet, oysters and clams, and steaks in the market. But if you can't make it to one of our Key Largo, Florida locations, we sell stone crabs, Alaskan King crabs, wild jumbo shrimp, jumbo lump crab, lobster tails, and more by the pound online and serve them in our restaurant.

We'll ship them freshly harvested from Florida waters, for your enjoyment, during the season -and frozen crabs during the remainder of the year, during the breeding season. 

If you are discovering the exceptional flavor and nutrition of stone crabs, sustainable seafood, or if you're a stone crab lover who hasn't ordered from Stone Crab before, we'd like to help you learn about stone crabs and our business. Here are some answers to some of our frequently asked questions by our customers.

Are the stone crab claws cooked before shipping? How do you store stone crab claws at home? How many medium stone crab claws are in a pound? When is stone crab claw season? Continue reading, and you'll become an expert in stone crab culture.

Stone crab claws should be eaten within 1-2 days for the best quality and superior taste. When you order them from Stone Crab, they will arrive cooked and ready to be enjoyed within 48 hours. They'll taste even better if you eat them the same day the package arrives.

The number of crab claws in a pound varies, depending upon the size of claws ordered. Here is a guideline:

  • Colossal: 2 claws per pound
  • Jumbo: 3-4 claws per pound
  • Large: 4 - 5 claws per pound
  • Select: 6-7 claws per pound
  • Medium: 7-8 claws per pound

A. See the guideline above regarding the estimated number of claws in each pound of the size you wish to order. The number of pounds of each size ordered determines the approximate number of claws in the package.

A. Stone crab claws get bruised by sea urchin spines when the crabs crack sea urchin shells to eat them. The spots may not be attractive. But they do not harm the stone crab meat.

A. Shipping is calculated at online checkout. The cost will depend upon the overall weight of each order and the destination.

A. When your stone crab order arrives, unpack the claws and rinse them under cold water. Place them in a bowl on top of a layer of ice. Then place a layer of ice on top. Place the bowl in the refrigerator. Drain the bowl and add more ice the next morning if you haven't been able to eat them the first day. It is best to serve the stone crabs within 48 hours of their arrival. The claws should not be cracked until you're ready to eat them.

A. We will cook your stone crabs before we ship them. They are cooked in our production facility the day they are caught. When you receive them, yes, they're pre-cooked and ready to dip in the delicious mustard sauce we include in your package.

A. Stone crab season is from October 15 each year until the next May. Florida state law ensures that stone crabs continue to thrive in the surrounding ocean. If you order them out of season, you will receive crabs frozen at the peak of freshness.

Fishers carefully catch stone crabs in traps and inspect them to ensure they meet the legal requirements for harvesting. Then, after removing the claw, the stone crab is dropped back into the ocean, where it will continue to live and thrive.

When scuba and snorkel harvesting, you must not use any gear that can crush or puncture the crab's body. You must also only collect up to a gallon of stone crab claws per day, with only two gallons aboard your boat at any time.

Fishers carefully catch stone crabs in traps and inspect them to ensure they meet the legal requirements for harvesting. Then, after removing the claw, the stone crab is dropped back into the ocean, where it will continue to live and thrive.

A stone crab's claw is measured from the bend in its claw to the tip of the claw. This is referred to as the propodus, and it must be at least 2 7/8" to be harvested.

It is illegal to harvest claws from an ovigerous female (a female with eggs). Fishers turn stone crabs upside down to ensure they don't have a sponge containing eggs on their undersides. If a sponge is seen, the crab is carefully placed back into the water.

Female stone crabs have a wide, round abdomen, while a male's abdomen is much longer and narrower.

Many people often ask, "Do stone crab claws grow back?" and the answer is, "yes!" Typically, it takes an adult stone crab about a year to regenerate its claw, while younger stone crabs can regenerate claws within a few months.

Survival depends on three factors: Whether the diaphragm at the base of the claw joint is damaged Whether the stone crab has lost one or two claws The age of the stone crab

Stone crabs that have lost both claws have to learn to become scavengers that can hide from predators. Since they no longer have claws, these stone crabs aren't able to easily feed or defend themselves, making them more vulnerable to predators.

Carefully extend the stone crab's claw away from its body to see a fingerprint-like mark inside. If it is unbroken, it is an original claw. If the mark has dashes, it has likely been regenerated.

Male stone crabs live up to seven or eight years, and females live up to eight or nine years.

Stone Crab season requires claw-cracking expertise; luckily, it is not difficult. Simply use a mallet or the back of a spoon to tap the claw along the knuckles carefully. Then use your hands to pull away pieces of the shell to reveal the meat inside.

If untracked, your stone crabs will last up to 48 hours. We recommend eating them the day you get them to get the best flavor.

During Stone Crab season, it's important to know how to cook your stone crab claws. They can be steamed, sauteed, boiled, baked, grilled, or reheated in the microwave!

A. Leftover claws can be stored in an open container and kept in the coldest part of your refrigerator. Or they may be kept in a cooler containing ice. Drain the water and add more ice periodically. Consume within 48 hours of the time you received them.

Stone Crab owns two fish houses in the Florida Keys that are supplied with fresh seafood daily. Our fishers operate over 40 boats to catch the best fish, lobsters, and crabs that we handle from catch to customer sale, so you can be certain they're of the highest quality. When it's Stone Crab season, we provide the best stone crab claws in the country.